Skip to main

Best Italian food in Red Bank

Savor the Essence of Italy Dining with a Modern Touch

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Organic Wine Poach Pear with Prosciutto & Goat Cheese

Gluten-free. Goat cheese stuffed wine poached pear & baked. Served with organic baby arugula wrapped with prosciutto di Parma. Topped with candied mixed nuts, and cranberries drizzled with a Cabernet fig vinaigrette.

Add Item

Rigatoni with Sausage & Broccoli Rabe

Broccoli rabe sautéed with mushrooms, open fire roasted peppers and home made Italian ground sausage. Finished in a Pinot Grigio wine sauce. Tossed with rigatoni pasta. Topped with shaved Parmigiana cheese, and drizzled with extra virgin olive oil. Can be modified with gluten free for extra cost.

Add Item

Spaghettini Amatriciana with Sausage

Sautéed home made Italian ground sausage, with mushrooms, shallots, peas, and apple wood bacon. Finished with our San Marzano pomodoro fresco with a touch of cream. Can be modified with gluten free for extra cost.

Add Item

Risotto Pescatore

Seared Faroe Island salmon. Wild jumbo shrimp, wild calamari, organic mussels & clams sautéed and finished in a white wine sauce. Served over our creamy saffron infused peas risotto. Drizzled with extra virgin olive oil from Puglia Italy. Gluten-free.

Add Item

Prime Pork Chop (16 oz)

Panko crusted double cut pork chop, pan seared to golden perfection. Served in a calvados honey reduction. Topped with goat cheese, and served with sautéed fresh vegetables & mixed roasted roots. (Pork should not be consumed Raw)

Add Item

Veal Paillard Milanese Style

Lightly breaded grass fed veal cutlet. Topped with an organic tricolor salad with fire roasted red peppers, cherry tomato and fresh burrata cheese. Finished with garlic aioli, and a shitake balsamic reduction.

Add Item

Welcome to Monticello Italian Restaurant

Welcome to Monticello Italian Restaurant
Located at 69 Broad St., steps away from the Count Basie Theatre, and a mere two blocks from the Navesink Water Front park. Monticello has been impressing lovers of fine food and impeccable service in a warm and casual atmosphere. Our dedicated and professional staff is eager to provide you with a memorable dining experience. Whether you desire a romantic dinner for two or a celebration for 80, Monticello is the perfect destination for all your entertaining needs.

REVIEWS' ARE IN

Best Italian Restaurant. Organic produce, wild seafood, hormone free chicken, prime meats and gluten free friendly

Our Philosophy : From The Vine to Your Table!

Our Philosophy : From The Vine to Your Table!
At Monticello’s, we are committed to using the freshest ingredients. Our on-site organic garden, available from June to October, ensures peak freshness. We select premium meats and seafood daily and serve only non-GMO, non-processed foods, hormone-free/antibiotic-free chicken, free-range eggs, wild-caught seafood, organic produce, all-natural pork, and homemade degreased stocks. Quality and freshness are our promise to you. Quality is our commitment to our guests.
Explore Our Menu
Order From Our Website

Order From Our Website

Craving something delicious? Skip the wait and order straight from our website! Quick, easy, and delivered right to your door.
Order Now

Explore the Culinary Delights

Take a visual tour through Monticello’s delectable Italian dishes and let the food speak for itself

A Refined Dining Experience at Monticello

A Refined Dining Experience at Monticello
Step into Monticello at Red Bank, where fresh ingredients and expert craftsmanship come together in every dish. From thoughtfully prepared pastas to expertly grilled meats and seafood, each plate is created with care and attention to detail. Enjoy a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for a relaxed meal or a special occasion.

Our on-site Organic Garden is Available From June to October

From the vine to your table!!

Reserve Your Table at Monticello

Reserve Your Table at Monticello
Ready to enjoy a delicious meal with us? Secure your table ahead of time for a stress-free dining experience! Whether it's a casual night out or a special occasion, we’ll have a spot waiting just for you.
Make a Reservation Now

Food Trailer Rental

Food Trailer Rental
Bring the flavor wherever you go with our food trailer rental service! Perfect for events, festivals, or private parties, our fully-equipped trailers let you serve delicious, fresh meals on the move. Customize your menu, set up easily, and delight your guests with a unique dining experience.
Book Your Trailer TodaY

Special Events & Private Parties

Special Events & Private Parties
Planning a baby shower, bridal shower, or brunch with friends? Monticello offers private party packages for up to 80 guests! Whether you're looking for a buffet or a personalized menu, we’ll tailor the experience to suit your needs. Ready to make your next event unforgettable?
Start Planning Your Special Day

🍽️ Catering with a Touch of Monticello

🍽️ Catering with a Touch of Monticello
Bring the taste of Monticello to your next event! Whether it's an intimate gathering or a grand celebration, our catering services provide a range of authentic Italian dishes made from the freshest ingredients. We’ll work with you to create a menu that suits your event and leaves your guests asking for more.
Let Us Cater Your Event

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Food is excellent Fresh, organically made. I've been going for a long time and still the best.

Joe C.

Joe C.

What a nice find. Dinner before the show at CBT. Unbelievable flavor in a simple Chicken Parmesan dish. Marinara sauce was jam packed with flavor, chicken was cooked perfectly, and the mozzarella was very creamy and delicious. Wild Berry s and gelato dessert was fresh and flavorful. Service was great. The server was always present and attentive.

Scott M.

Scott M.

My boyfriend and I wanted to try a new restaurant for date night. After reading lots of great reviews, we gave Monticello a try. We agreed that the entire experience was a 10/10! We sat outside. The outdoor seating area is small and cozy without being crowded. The food was incredible. I had the rigatoni with sausage and broccoli rabe and he had chicken parm. I brought a bottle of wine, and we had the lava cake dessert. (It was amazing.) I’m not exaggerating… I think this is my new favorite restaurant. We will be back!

Cheryl J.

Cheryl J.

Join Monticello’s Earn Rewards with Every Bite

Join Monticello’s Earn Rewards with Every Bite

Join Monticello’s loyalty program and start earning rewards for every meal you enjoy. Exclusive offers, we make every visit a little sweeter. The more you dine, the more you’ll save and indulge in special perks!

Frequently asked questions

We serve Dinner

Yes, we offer Takeout and Delivery

We are located in Red Bank, NJ at 69 Broad St

Our location